This post and photos may contain Amazon or other affiliate links. If you purchase something through any link, I may receive a small commission at no extra charge to you. Any supplies used may be given to me free of charge, however, all projects and opinions are my own.
Cookie butter recipes you have to try! This collection of recipes uses your favorite cookie butter spread to make simple treats or elaborate desserts. Whether it’s Trader Joe’s cookie butter, Biscoff cookie butter, Lotus or another brand, you’ll find easy recipes kids and families will love!
RECIPES USING COOKIE BUTTER YOUR FAMILY WILL LOVE!
This post contains affiliate links. I only recommend products or services I use personally and believe would be a good fit for my readers. This comes at no added cost to you!
Have we got a list for you! Find cookies, truffles, cupcakes, and more all using your favorite cookie butter spread!
—Want the recipes right now? Don’t want to learn everything there is to know about cookie butter? No problem! Simply scroll straight to the bottom! You’ll find the recipes after the first collage photo of recipes!—
What are the ingredients for cookie butter?
The main ingredient for all cookie butter spreads is butter cookies that are made with brown sugar and spices. You can find them in most European countries, and they are typically served around the Christmas holiday season. The first time I was introduced to a cookie butter spread was while shopping in December in Germany. One of the booths at a Christmas market was allowing samples of Lotus cookie butter. It was divine!
Cookie butter can be either creamy of crunchy. The basic ingredients for cookie butter spread are crushed up speculoos cookies, butter, sugar, oils and a bit more cinnamon and nutmeg. Trader Joe markets it as “a deliciously unusual spread reminiscent of gingerbread and made with crushed biscuits”. I agree that the butter cookies have a distinct taste, but I wouldn’t have associated it with gingerbread. What about you? I mean to me gingerbread has a strong ginger flavor and some spice to it, like my gingerbread reindeer cookies have.
Growing up, my dad used to have my mom put the windmill speculoos cookies in his lunch box. I had forgotten about them until I had a Biscoff cookie served to me on an international flight. It seems like these speculoos cookies are a favorite snack on flights. I’ve even started to get Biscoff cookies instead of pretzels on domestic US flights. There are lots of types of cookie butter cookies, once you know the basic brown sugar cinnamon flavor, you’ll spot them all over the place!
How can I use cookie butter in baking?
Cookie butter is simple to use in your baking recipes. You can simply substitute in any recipe that calls for peanut butter. It’s really that easy. If it’s a bit too thick, and your struggling, you can microwave it just the slightest amount to make it softer. The brown sugar, cinnamon and nutmeg add a nice flavor, but it doesn’t have to be used individually. It is complimented well with both dark chocolate and white chocolate.
Is Cookie Butter Gluten Free?
Sadly it is not. I know, it’s torture my friends. I know I mentioned trying it on international flights and during Christmas markets in Germany, but that was before I was diagnosed with Celiac. So I still remember the incredible taste. I have yet to find a speculoos cookie that is gluten free either. So until Trader Joe’s decides to start selling them, we are stuck making our own. I would suggest using a 1-1 gluten free flour mix with a recipe for speculoos cookies. Let me know if you find a brown sugar cinnamon butter cookie recipe you love!
Also, those windmill cookies can sometimes contain nuts. So if you have a nut allergy, you want to make sure you always double check packages.
Can I make my own cookie butter?
Absolutely! If you have cookie butter cookies, it would be fun to make your own, since you could control the ingredients. Simply adjust to find the portion of ingredients that you prefer. This would be ideal if you had a recipe for gluten free cookie butter cookies, since I have been unable to find a gluten free cookie butter spread! If you don’t have specific needs though, it’s just as easy to buy store bought cookie butter.
Creamy Cookie Butter VS Crunchy Cookie Butter?
The choice is up to you! Just like peanut butter, they can each offer a different take to a recipe. They even sell a cocoa swirl!
If you do prefer crunchy cookie butter and are cookie with it, remember you can always add in some crushed cookies to add to the texture even more.
What can I use Cookie Butter on?
- apple slices
- speculoos butter cookies
- pancakes / waffles
- sugar cookies
- pear slices
The list really is endless and up to you! Popcorn is one of my favorites, this sweet and savory speculoos cookie butter popcorn is a popular recipe here on Major Hoff Takes A Wife. Probably because it takes about 5 minutes to make and tastes like a gourmet recipe from a homemade popcorn shop!
Where can I buy Cookie Butter?
It’s getting much easier to buy speculoos cookie spread, mainly because of the many brands like Trader Joe’s, Biscoff, Lotus, and even store brands like HEB. HEB is a Texas grocery chain that sells their own mixture! If you don’t live by a Trader Joe’s or a Cost Plus World Market that carries it, you can always order off of Amazon!
You’ll find that each brand has it’s own distinct taste. It is fun to decide which is your favorite. We held a family taste testing to pick ours! Of course, everyone picked something different!
If you don’t have enough time to whip up one of these fantastic cookie butter dessert recipes, you can always just grab a cup of tea or coffee and nibble on some speculoos cookies! Now for what you’ve been waiting for!
This collection of homemade cookie butter recipes will wow you! Simply use Trader Joes Cookie butter, Lotus Biscoff, or another speculoos spread! Learn how to make cupcakes, no bake snacks, brownies, and other easy desserts. The best have chocolate too! Perfect snacks for those cookie butter lovers in your life!
Favorite Recipes using Cookie Butter:
So which one is your favorite? I’ll be honest and tell you there are too many good ones to pick a favorite! It’s just too hard!
I’m hoping to add some more cookie butter recipes to the Major Hoff Takes A Wife recipe collection. Is there a recipe that you are dying to try that you don’t see here? I’d love to hear suggestions! I’m really in a big cookie mood, and just made these double mocha caramel bars this week which my kiddos adore!
Please feel free to pin the collages to your favorite Pinterest boards so that others can see all the fantastic recipes!
*** Special thanks to all the bloggers that allowed me to link to their amazing recipes!
I believe EVERYONE has a story, this blog shares mine.